If noise were a drug, who would take it?
‘Doctor, Doctor, I feel like a pair of curtains!’
‘Well, pull yourself together and sit down.’
Of course I say this in jest; a doctor should be attentive to his patient’s needs, and you are the patient. You are an innocent bystander yet a child of your age, a victim of contemporary life. We live in a world that offers us distraction because we are the product.
While Karl Marx famously saw religion as opium for the masses, if he had been alive in today’s society, he may have found a more legitimate target for his complaints. Noise, not religion, is the opium. Noise is the sedative, the silencer of bold speech and deep thought. While Marx claimed that the victim of religion was someone simple who can’t come to grips with suffering, the victim of this new sedative is suffering from the pathological inability to endure silence.
They drown their silence with noise.
When I talk about noise, I’m not simply talking about an auditory stimulus. What I mean is something more encapsulating: noise as a distraction. Music, for example, can be a distraction and affect how we think both in the short term and the long term. But so can that with which we feed our eyes. And once an image is etched into the mind, it cannot be unseen, especially if it is of a ghastly or shocking nature. Its noise can continue to haunt its victim far into the future.
Whatever the particular stimulus might be, the nuance I want to convey is that this grasping for noise is something that ultimately robs us of inner control.
One person is listening to music on the train. Is he doing so because he gets gnawingly anxious when facing what seems like a state of emptiness, and takes out his earphones in order to escape from his inner reality? Maybe not. Maybe the person next to him reading a book is the anxious one.
Let’s explore this more deeply. Am I happy to spend time alone with my own thoughts? Would I be anxious, angry, or simply uncomfortable walking to the train station and waiting on the platform with no other sensory input than the sound of traffic, cold air freezing my nostrils and my eyes watching the countdown of minutes until the train arrives?
In his Penseés, Blaise Pascal (1623–1662) famously said: ‘All of humanity’s problems stem from man’s inability to sit quietly in a room alone.’ If that were true back then, when there was no internet and very low literacy rates, how true is it now in a world where advertisement is a demon after our attention.
Examine your conscience. If silence makes you uncomfortable, you’ve got a symptom. Do I reach for my phone out of a mindless reflex without thinking, like a nervous twitch?
This reminds me of the ‘soma’ from Huxley’s Brave New World, a vapid substance that makes people less human. Our morning trains can look like that: our fellow commuters seemingly in a trance, fixated on the square to oblivion they hold in their hands. And the soma of our brave new world is the short-form video—TikTok, Reels, Shorts—expertly crafted to ensnare the user.
Yet this virus is not limited to the gaudy spectacle of short form video. Its rot has seeped into all aspects of our lives. While falling into a ‘doom scroll’ essentially means embracing a descent into the digital catacomb given to us by our social media algorithms, such a descent can also be found in things such as news outlets.
With the world at our fingertips, we become more fragmented in our real world relationships. In the presence of others, our mind wanders and our hand follows suit. Without consciously willing it, we’ve taken our phone out, and shut off our friend. Implicitly, by doing this, I am saying that the digital void is more compelling than the person sitting right there, who would feel more loved if I was able to focus.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #7 of Bedrock Magazine
Recent years have brought widespread debate about the need to reduce children’s screen time. Campaigns have successfully banned social media for under-16s, and many schools now operate as smartphone-free environments. The European Medical Journal has published extensive research showing the harm excessive screen use causes to young minds, linking it to delays in speech development, declines in behaviour, and damage to physical and mental health.
I want to address a related issue that lies at the heart of this problem: the need for educators to return to a form of education that better serves young people and society. I advocate for a classical, or liberal arts, education. Many simply call this the traditional model of teaching and learning, and for more than two thousand years, this approach shaped education across the Western world. Today, Britain has largely abandoned it. Reviving classical education could provide the solution to many of the challenges modern society now faces.
I would argue that too many children in Britain no longer display the fundamental qualities of healthy development and a happy childhood. I am often dismayed at children’s communication skills; many possess limited speech and language skills, and too few speak confidently in public, read aloud with assurance, or engage in adult conversation. More recently, I have also noticed a general dullness in children. Too often they lack the curiosity, imagination, or sense of wonder that should be filling every young heart and mind. I refer to children between the ages of three and sixteen in Britain in 2026, a generation growing up in an age of technology that exerts constant influence from every direction. I do not wish to comment on matters of the home, but instead I wish to consider what schools should provide. My views draw on my own observations, my experience teaching in both the state and private sectors, my work as a headteacher, my role in founding England’s first classical school, and, above all, my experience as the mother of three children.
Children today face challenges unlike those of previous generations. Working-class children in Victorian England, for example, often swept chimneys or laboured in coal mines from the age of five. I am confident that young people today no doubt feel grateful that they no longer endure such gruelling physical work. However, they face a different threat: rapid technological change and reliance. Technology has brought speed, efficiency, and convenience, but at the cost of children’s education. Our classrooms now bear the consequences of a failed educational experiment. Fortunately, countries such as Sweden and Finland have begun to reduce classroom technology after research linked excessive screen use to poorer outcomes for children. Technology now shapes the education of children across every demographic in Great Britain. Educationalists and policymakers must reconsider the model of education they offer despite the many challenges. Schools must raise their expectations for curriculum content, teaching methods, and the classroom environment.
The progressive model of education, now dominant in British schools, has contributed to many of the difficulties young people face. A return to a more traditional model will help address those challenges.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #7 of Bedrock Magazine.
In moments of loss and moments of grief, I have found genuine solace in a work of art.
Art has helped me to look at these situations with a perspective of hope. Through artistic expression, I have been able to dwell on those feelings without being overwhelmed by them, and to transform them into something beautiful and, in a quiet way, meaningful for others.
The fact that the contemplation of my work could bring joy to someone else gave a new sense to that pain. It offered me deep consolation, because my suffering no longer seemed pointless, but rather the source of something beautiful. Some of my favourite authors, such as Mario Vargas Llosa, have emphasized this same idea, affirming that everything can be transformed into beauty—in his case, through literature.
Dostoevsky has Prince Myshkin say in his novel The Idiot (1869) that ‘Beauty will save the world.’ This sentence, often quoted and rarely understood, does not stem from naive aesthetics, but from a spiritual insight. Dostoevsky does not mean external or superficial beauty, but that which is an expression of Goodness and Truth. A beauty that redeems because it transforms the heart. For him, it was a symbol of divine harmony, a reflection of the divine in a world of suffering and fragmentation.
It might have happened to you too: a tough situation makes it hard to see any hope, but then a moment of beauty—a sunset, a favourite song, or the smile of someone you love—can lift your spirits and remind you that not everything is lost.
The ancient philosophers—Plato, Socrates, and Aristotle—already saw beauty not as mere decoration, but as an essential characteristic of Goodness. For Plato, in the Symposium and Phaedrus, love for beauty leads the soul to the knowledge of the True. The ideal of kalokagathia, the unity of kalos (beautiful) and agathos (good), in classical culture expressed the conviction that the beautiful and the good are inseparable. Beauty reveals goodness, and goodness radiates beauty.
From my own experience, there have been moments when I was tempted to act in ways that were unkind, either to others or to myself. In those moments, simply pausing to take in beauty could stop me. I remember walking by the sea on a clear day, watching the sunlight touch the water and the sea glow a bright, transparent blue. Seeing something so beautiful made me realize that if this exists, there must be something better to aspire to—and that I shouldn’t settle for a lesser version of myself. In this way, beauty guided me toward goodness and helped me make better choices.
Pope Benedict XVI encourages such an approach in his 2009 address to artists in the Sistine Chapel: ‘True beauty attracts man, draws him out of himself, elevates him, and transports him. It opens his heart and reason to grasp the depth of reality.’
This means that beauty is not only capable of touching hearts sentimentally but is a form of knowledge and experience of reality. Spiritual realities find in it a language more eloquent than terms and abstractions, because it allows a direct encounter with things themselves.
Sometimes, in life, it can happen that we fall in love with someone. In those moments, we are not thinking in abstract concepts or complex ideas. Deep down, we just know we love that person—through the beauty we perceive in them, both in their appearance and in their character. We recognize their essence in the sparkle of their eyes or the warmth of their smile. If we were to write a poem about them, we would have plenty of material to work with, because we have already understood the hidden beauty that lives within them.
In this sense, art has a dual task: it not only reflects the world but transforms it by revealing the invisible—feelings, values, and hidden harmony often overlooked in everyday life. True art teaches us to see with new eyes and to cultivate sensitivity: it helps us recognize the true, the good, and the beautiful in our own lives. Yet art is not just inspiration; it is also craft. Technical mastery is more than skill: it requires discipline, patience, and love for detail. Only in this way can beauty endure and not remain fleeting. In a ‘throwaway’ culture, the true artist reminds us that what is essential requires time, dedication, and fidelity, and that what is created with care will retain its meaning and its purpose.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #6 of Bedrock Magazine.
Ecclesiastes is not the happiest book of the Bible. Despite being one of the most famous (it is, for example, consistently ranked by atheists as their favorite biblical book), its overall tone and message is inexorably pessimistic. Throughout its twelve chapters, the Preacher repeatedly sets up the objects and pursuits that people find the most meaningful, from sensual pleasure to marriage and family, academic learning, business, and even the contemplation of God, only to ‘take a wrecking ball to them’ (to use a favorite phrase of my Old Testament professor, Dr. Schmiedicke) with his familiar refrain: ‘vanity of vanities, all is vanity.’ Nothing seems to escape his systematic demolition—with one notable exception. When the Preacher comes to the topic of friendship, he has only positive words to say:
‘It is better therefore that two should be together, than one: for they have the advantage of their society: If one fall he shall be supported by the other: woe to him that is alone, for when he falleth, he hath none to lift him up. And if two lie together, they shall warm one another: how shall one alone be warmed? And if a man prevail against one, two shall withstand him: a threefold cord is not easily broken.’ (Ecclesiastes 4:9-12, DRB)
Friendship has been celebrated by the wisest thinkers and leaders in history, from the sacred writers of the Bible to Cicero, Seneca, Aelred of Rievaulx, Montaigne and C.S. Lewis, to name just a few, but none has given a more thorough and penetrating treatment of it than Aristotle. The Philosopher divided friendship into three types: utility, pleasure or delight, and virtue. Each type presupposes reciprocal benevolence or ‘well-wishing’ between persons and some degree of shared life. Friendship of utility is the bond of mutual assistance: think coworkers, partners in the police service, sport teammates, or squad members on the battlefield. The people involved may not be interested in one another beyond their shared task, or even particularly like each other, but they have a basic form of friendship nonetheless, one that can be quite profound even to the point of sacrificing one’s life for another.
Friendship of pleasure takes this a bit further, with a greater intimacy and love. This relationship comes about from mutual interests and enjoyment of one another’s company—not merely helping out in a common job but actually delighting in the other person’s good. This form of friendship is perfected by the final type, friendship of virtue, wherein friends so love one another that they are even willing to correct faults, encourage growth in virtue, and endure the greatest internal or external struggles in life for a good end. This is the pinnacle of friendship according to Aristotle.
So what type of friendship is highlighted by Ecclesiastes? It must be admitted that the Preacher’s focus is predominantly pragmatic. He sees some use and practical benefit from friendship—not so much for moral formation or even shared enjoyment but to support one another, to pick each other up when you fall, to share warmth in the cold, and to withstand adversities together rather than alone. All of these are true and legitimate benefits of friendship, but they fail to reach the heights of friendship of pleasure, much less friendship of virtue, as envisioned by Aristotle (and shown in more optimistic passages of Scripture).
One of the most noteworthy features of the 20th century was its preponderance of literary friendship networks. These groups varied by size, duration, and influence, but they continued to appear in each decade and were especially influential around the time of the World Wars. They included some that are more familiar today, such as the Bloomsbury Group (Virginia Woolf, E.M. Forster, et al.), the Modernists/Imagists (Wyndham Lewis, Ezra Pound, T.S. Eliot, et al.), the Beat Generation (Allen Ginsberg, Jack Kerouac, et al.), and some more obscure.
None of these literary associations, however, exemplified true friendship as did one in particular: the Inklings, an Oxford-based circle whose members fluctuated over time but most prominently included C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, Charles Williams, and Owen Barfield. Unlike most other literary groups at this time, the Inklings were not only more organized and consistent in their meetings, but their shared Christian faith, love of Western tradition, and mutual interests in language, literature, philosophy, and theology set them apart from all others. For almost twenty years, c. 1931-1949, the Inklings met to critique one another’s current projects, often quite scathingly, to discuss deep subjects and ideological differences between them, and most of all to share a pint and hearty laughs in a respite from the dreariness, anxiety, and stress of life which only authentic friendship can provide. For this reason, Tolkien once called their meetings ‘the feast of reason and flow of soul’ (Letter 89).
For many people today, men most of all, friendship can be a true rarity. Studies and surveys repeatedly show that most people can count only one or two close friends in their lives, even those with a wide network of acquaintances, both online and off. While this might seem like bad news, it also shows an important truth that is still known even if only implicitly and intuitively: friendship is different than any other type of relationship. Simply having hundreds or thousands of followers online is not the same as having even one close friend.
Indeed, Aristotle’s distinction of friendships is (like most of his ideas) just common sense: no matter how much we may like our coworkers or teammates, or how much fun we might have with our poker buddies, our readers on Substack, or our kinship on The Lord of the Rings Online, we still know deep down that this is different from a true friendship. If someone is not willing to correct us, to stand by us no matter what, to share in our sufferings and sorrows, and if we are not willing to do the same for them, then they are not a true friend. Merely sharing common interests, or even being related by blood or marriage, is not the same as having an authentic friendship.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #6 of Bedrock Magazine.
Look closely at the frost creeping across a windowpane on a winter morning, and you’ll see delicate ice patterns that look uncannily like ferns. The same geometry that governs the growth of leaves also governs the crystallization of water. Or think of a river delta seen from above: its vast branching channels mirror the thread-like tributaries of veins in a leaf. The world is patterned with endlessly repeating motifs that echo across scale. These are fractals. Unlike the clean, symmetrical forms of classical geometry (squares, cylinders, cones, circles), the shapes of life are irregular. Fractals embody the roughness of reality itself, suggesting that complexity and chaos are intrinsic conditions of nature, and they offer a lens through which to contemplate identity, interconnectedness, and the deep structures of existence.
What Is a Fractal?
Mathematically, a fractal is a complex geometric shape that can be split into parts, each of which is a smaller yet similar copy of the whole. This property, called self-similarity, means that as you zoom in, the same patterns recur at different scales. The famous Mandelbrot set—an infinitely complex shape generated by a simple iterative formula—is perhaps the most iconic example. Fractals manifest everywhere: in the branching of trees, the veins of leaves, the jagged outlines of coastlines, the turbulence of clouds, and the pathways of lightning.
Benoit Mandelbrot, the mathematician who coined the term fractal, once remarked:
‘Clouds are not spheres, mountains are not cones, coastlines are not circles, and bark is not smooth, nor does lightning travel in a straight line.’ Fractals are, in short, the geometry of the nonlinear, the mathematics of nature as it really is.
Roughness and the Challenge to Geometry
Traditional Euclidean geometry, with its neat lines and perfect shapes, fails to capture the messy intricacy of the natural world. In contrast, fractal geometry provides a language for describing irregular forms, the kinds that abound in forests, rivers, and bodies. It deals with objects that are ‘interdimensional’, fitting somewhere between ordinary dimensions. A coastline, for example, is more than a line but less than a surface. This in-betweenness—the infinite stretch between dimensions—is part of what makes fractals both mathematically strange and philosophically suggestive.
Mandelbrot’s main contribution was not a final proof but a new way of asking questions. What if roughness itself were a fundamental property of reality? What if complexity is not a deviation from the norm, but the norm itself?
Fractals in Nature and the Body
Fractals are not just aesthetic patterns but functional architectures. The branching of lungs, kidneys, and blood vessels allows a vast surface area within a compact volume. Neurons replicate fractal-like pathways, optimizing communication across the brain. Spirals repeat from the tiny chambers of a nautilus shell to the swirl of a sunflower’s florets and all the way to the spiral arms of galaxies. These repetitions suggest a unity of principles across vastly different scales.
In short, the whole is reflected in the parts. What we see in the microcosm mirrors what we see in the macrocosm. This insight is not just biological but also metaphysical. It suggests that reality is composed of recurring motifs, patterns that transcend size or scale.
The Philosophy of Self-Similarity
The concept of self-similarity has profound implications that extend beyond mathematics. Just as a fractal retains its identity at every level of magnification, so too might the human self persist through the different scales of experience. We grow, we change, we pass through stages of life, yet some core essence remains persistent and recognizable.
Self-similarity also suggests that patterns in human behavior recur. Sigmund Freud observed that we are compelled to repeat, to reenact early patterns in new contexts. These repetitions can be destructive, locking us into cycles of compulsion, but they can also be generative, grounding us in a continuity of self. Fractals, with their recursive loops, illuminate this rhythm of repetition that underlies both the psyche and the cosmos.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #5 of Bedrock Magazine.
It is the thirteenth century. Louis IX, the sainted king of France, sits beneath an oak at Vincennes and calls the poor to speak. They come with trodden shoes and crumpled papers; he listens, asks, and judges. At times, he remits a fine because a rule, sound in the main, would crush someone in this case; at times he upholds the penalty and gives from his purse, so justice does not turn to hunger. He has officers and staff enough to do this work, yet he comes in person.
This episode from centuries ago matters, because how we read affairs like it shapes how we judge our own roles, such as parent, colleague, and neighbour. By much contemporary praise, to do good in person like this is a handsome flourish; good if one fancies it, optional if one does not. Once free choice, plain consent, and fair hearing are met, the moral boxes are ticked. Whether the king himself listens or hands the task to magistrates belongs to taste, show, or saved time.
Let me sketch an older way of thinking, one that starts with ends. By ‘end’, I mean what a thing is for, by nature: its aim or purpose. This older view has no canonical defender, since it has been common across many societies and eras. We can borrow a term from the Scottish philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre and call it the ‘heroic’ point of view. It is so called because it is typical of what MacIntyre calls heroic societies—cultures that aim to form heroic persons foremost, with good actions as a by-product of forming heroic individuals. Examples include Aristotle, the Bible, Homer, Confucius, Plato, and mediaeval Christendom, among many others.
The ‘heroic’ outlook asks first what the ends of a role are, and which duties follow from those ends. Rights matter, but chiefly as shields for duties set by nature. In this older mindset, a life’s end is not ‘a goal I happen to want’, but a good I ought to want because it fits the kind of being I am. One scholar of Aristotle, R.A. Gauthier, calls it ‘a duty to be happy’: fulfilling what we are made for. If that jars our ears, it may be because we treat happiness as a private feeling. In the heroic tongue, it is a public yardstick that weighs a life according to its purpose. From this end follow duties: learn, act justly, serve the common good, keep promises, foster friendship. From those duties, rights take shape. A right to counsel is not mere kindness; it guards the court’s duty to judge fairly. We have ends, then duties, then rights.
An influential, anti-perfectionist modern view, prominent since the seventeenth century, largely flips this order. Thinkers such as Hobbes, Locke, Mill, and Kant tend to bracket claims about stable purposes written into nature. If there are no fixed ends, there can be no common duties grounded in what things are. Hobbes is bluntest: persons are one-off units with their own wants and fears; you cannot generalise from one to another. Morality must be articulated from what people actually want, not what they should want. It starts with rights, and treats duty mostly as non-interference: do not coerce, do not cheat, keep consent plain. Goodness is staying within the rails. Whether deeds fit a role, or some ways of living are better as human lives, falls outside moral talk. The upshot is a framework of rules for private pursuits.
Yet duty will not stay out. Duty (or ‘ought’) is the essence of ethics, hence without some notion of duty there are no morals. It is reintroduced, not as a call to grasp true human purposes, but as a call to respect each person’s chase after his own ends. In Locke, the heart of ethics is non-interference: do not trespass on the other’s private pursuit if he does not trespass on yours. In Mill, the aim is to widen each person’s room for private pleasures: make more space for private wants and call that the common good. In Kant, the dress is sterner, but the same frame holds: to be moral is to honour others as self-ruling choosers, never using them merely as means. Duty becomes the strict demand to honour choice as such.
Stitch these together and a single ‘end’ appears: the universalisation of private desire. The good society is one where each goes their own way, checked only by the equal going of all the others. That reversal leaves us tongue-tied when we most need plain speech. We do, in fact, admire acts that show good character without swelling anyone’s list of claims, merely steering clear of other people’s wants, and riding on ‘autonomy’. We admire the judge who steps down from a case technically allowed, because justice must not only be done but be seen. We admire the publisher who turns down a coarse bestseller that would sell, because it would coarsen the culture they are meant to serve and improve. A rights-first view can call these ‘permitted’, perhaps ‘good if you like that sort of thing’, but cannot say why they fit judging or publishing. It lines things up, but it does not rank them. None of this downplays modern safeguards; individualism and consent are real gains. The question is how to locate them within a fuller account of what our roles are for.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #5 of Bedrock Magazine.
On the 8th of September 1936, three urbane, liberal and educated men set fire to an RAF training camp in north Wales, all for the love of words. Saunders Lewis, D. J. Williams and Lewis Valentine, founding members of the party we now call Plaid Cymru and pronounce wrongly, knew that the building was empty. No-one came to any harm, and the three men turned themselves in at Pwllheli police station in keeping with the principles of mostly peaceful civil disobedience. It is said that they spent the evening at His Majesty’s displeasure conducting poetic criticism with the sergeant on duty.
Lewis, Williams and Valentine—respectively a university lecturer, a grammar school teacher and a Baptist minister, each in the first flush of middle age and a voluted pillar of the community—gave up tea and crosswords for kerosene out of literary necessity. Stanley Baldwin’s government, in order to build the RAF facility at Penyberth, had demolished a house associated for centuries with patrons of Welsh poetry; that rulers speaking some strange, barbaric language should rob the cradle of their native tongue to build a ‘bombing school’ was more than these three men of refinement could bear. Naturally, the state did its best to prove them right: at their trial, removed from Caernarfon to the Old Bailey, Lewis and Williams were forbidden to speak in Welsh. (Valentine was permitted to do so on the grounds that, unlike his co-defendants educated at Liverpool and Oxford, he could not be shown to be fluent in English—surely proof of the dangers of higher education.)
After serving nine months in Wormwood Scrubs, Britain’s least euphonious prison, and emerging not much the worse for wear, the three set about the task of developing respectable literary careers. Williams published a couple of volumes of autobiography before his death compelled him to hand over his life-story to his biographers. Valentine edited several Welsh-language newspapers. Lewis was the most remarkable of the three: although also remembered today as a writer of sublime poetry and drama, a lonely traditional Catholic voice in first nonconformist and then secular Wales, and a Chestertonian distributist of equal wit and grump, his name is most associated with a Welsh-language radio address which he gave in 1962. Titled Tynged yr Iaith (‘The Fate of the Language’), and delivered in Lewis’s apocalyptically solemn idiom, it suggested that, if swords were not drawn and torches not lit at once, the last Welsh speaker would, before the end of the century, die.
Many other such speeches have been given by many more sonorous speakers: the historian Geraint H. Jenkins describes Lewis as a reedy-voiced wearer of bow ties, undeservedly suggesting more Pee-wee Herman than a silken intellect of the same cut as W. B. Yeats and Paul Claudel. Nonetheless, Lewis’s words fell in dry grass, and fired the nation. Within months, the newly-founded Cymdeithas yr Iaith Gymraeg (‘Welsh Language Society’) began a direct action campaign which would lead to the passing of the Welsh Language Acts of 1967 and 1993, giving Welsh the same status as English in Wales. In our day, when Welsh is a tongue for literature, education, and government, it would not be too much to say that Saunders Lewis single-handedly saved the Welsh language.
Why do any of this? Why go to prison for the sake of words? Even in Lewis’s time, there were vanishingly few Welsh speakers who did not also speak English; now, there are thought to be none. He was a writer of terrible beauty in English just as in Welsh. What did he, or his country, have to gain?
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #4 of Bedrock Magazine.
Everyone has at some stage in their life experienced a feeling of wonder, either when we experience the scale and majesty of a landscape, or when we reflect upon the complexities of human societies and cultures or scientific marvels.
We all know that feeling of being drawn into something beyond ourselves which speaks to us, poses questions, and offers up a rich variety of answers to those questions. Wonder is one of the most basic and fundamental human experiences, since it is the mode of being by which the human person engages rationally with experience. Hence why we say things like, ‘I wonder why…’ which reveals this rational exploration that wonder draws us into.
This, however, is not always obvious. While I think we all desire to grow in a deeper experience of wonder throughout our lives, with the speed of daily life we can at times struggle to reflect on what the sources of wonder are for us, and so fail to develop and cultivate a ‘wonder-full’ life.
There are certain parts of life which I think particularly draw us into wonder. Some of these are ordinary experiences, often overlooked and rarely reflected on. Others are rather nuanced and subtle, often laborious to discover, but their treasures are greatly rewarding.
One of the more ordinary and overlooked is the experience of the subjective self. While science can explain many aspects of the human person, such as our biological, chemical and physical structure, it is also true that consciousness and the subjective self have not been (and, arguably, can never be) explained by the sciences. This is not to say that they are irrational, but that they are not examinable by the narrow vision of science. The scientific method seeks the physical and material aspects of experience. This narrowing of its scope of inquiry makes it more powerful at deducing knowledge within its domain, but a priori excludes making statements about aspects of reality outside of this scope. Therefore, different forms of reflection are necessary to engage with realities beyond the reach of science.
Philosophers have been discussing such topics for thousands of years. Specific answers given by these philosophers are not especially of interest here; what I wish to focus on is the fact that this rather common aspect of human experience has been the source of so much thinking, and has left man wondering about what it is to be a ‘person’ for so long. The majority of philosophers at least accept certain phenomenological aspects of the subjective self, such as the notion that he is conscious and self-aware; that he has a will, intellect and memory; that he lives, and dies. While they might have different opinions on how to understand these things and how they fit together, they all accept the common experiences that the subjective self has. Even the ‘solipsist’, a person who thinks only they exist, accepts these things for themselves, even if they deny the consciousness of others. The mystery of human consciousness and the subjective self, therefore, seems to be a key area of wonder for all types of philosophers.
In modern times, many aspects of reality have revealed themselves to be intrinsically and deeply mysterious. Quantum Mechanics, a field of physics which explains the structure of reality at its smallest scale, has unveiled some of the mysteries of the world at the most basic foundations of physical reality. One of the founders of Quantum Mechanical Theory, Paul Dirac, argued that this was to be expected on almost philosophical grounds since we intuitively recognize that there is a difference in scale between big and small things, and hence they must have a different kind of physics which differentiates this scale. This had started to become clear in the years preceding Dirac as people studied physical properties of matter, such as those related to pressure and heat. Ludwig Boltzmann resurrected the Greek theory of atoms to try and understand why matter had a sense of scale, and hence the capacity to display some different physical realities to those covered by the traditional Newtonian Physics that came before.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #4 of Bedrock Magazine.
Every day something challenges our sense of human worth. Maybe it is the frustration of dismissing a slow cashier as “incompetent” when they are struggling to make ends meet, or the temptation to stroll past a homeless person without a second thought, reducing them to a problem rather than a person. Perhaps it is the way we judge a coworker’s worth by their output or roll our eyes at an elderly relative’s repeated stories, as if their value fades with age. In a world that celebrates speed, success, and social media perfection, it is easy to slip into seeing people – including ourselves – through a dehumanizing lens, measuring worth by what someone can do or how they appear. The erosion of shared moral principles has led to a society which increasingly measures human worth by utility, productivity, or social capital.
At the heart of our daily struggles lies a deeper truth: every person has inherent value, no matter their circumstances. This article explores how an old but powerful idea – inherent human dignity – can help us navigate life’s challenges. It draws from the wisdom of St. Thomas Aquinas and of the 16th-century Iberian Scholastics whose insights are not just for scholars: they speak to the everyday choices we make at home, work, or in our communities.
The idea that every person has worth simply because they are human is closely related to a tradition called natural law, which says there is a universal moral order built into who we are. Think about the moments when you feel a tug to do the right thing even when it is hard – when you help a neighbour, speak up when someone is treated unfairly, etc. That is your reason kicking-in, sensing what is good for yourself and others, tapping into that sense of right and wrong which is part of being human.
Natural law is a concept with ancient roots in Greek and Roman philosophy. Cicero wrote of a law that does not arise from opinion but from nature, binding all human beings of all times. Aristotle described natural law as that which “has force always and everywhere,” not because we agree upon it, but because it reflects the order of nature itself.
Christian theology absorbed and developed this tradition. St. Thomas Aquinas defined natural law as “the rational creature’s participation in the eternal law”. For Aquinas, natural law is not imposed externally but written into the very fabric of human nature. Through reason, every person can discern basic moral truths about what is good and evil, what promotes human flourishing and what does harm. All humans, by nature of their rationality and freedom, share a moral capacity to understand and pursue what is good. It is from this premise that the Thomistic tradition builds its case for universal human dignity: each person possesses intrinsic worth simply by being a human being, a dignity which is not bestowed by society or law, nor is it earned through achievement.
This perspective shifts how we handle daily life. Picture yourself at the grocery store, where a cashier with a disability is moving slower than you would like. It is tempting to see them as a delay, but natural law reminds us that their worth is not tied to speed or productivity – it is in their humanity, same as yours. This might inspire you to offer a kind word or a bit of patience instead of frustration. Or think about a family member with a chronic illness who needs extra care. Society might whisper that their “usefulness” is gone, but Aquinas would say their dignity remains unchanged. This can guide you to prioritize their comfort and respect, even when it is demanding.
In bigger issues – like debates over healthcare, workplace fairness, or even how technology like AI is used – this lens helps us focus. Are we using these systems to lift people up or reducing them to data points? By rooting our choices in human dignity, we make decisions that value people over convenience or profit.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #3 of Bedrock Magazine.
Have you ever faced a particular challenge in your life as a result of circumstances spiralling out of control? Something awful that brought on a feeling of shame – something that you couldn’t face, something that you couldn’t talk about?
I once knew a man, not dissimilar to me. The other morning I caught a glimpse of him in the mirror; he’d aged somewhat, grey haired and wrinkled. His blue eyes spoke to me.
This is a true tale about a man, an ordinary man, known to some as John. It is also a true story about a United States military officer – Admiral James Stockdale. This could be your story. Here I present a story of hope.
John was an optimist. A positive and hardworking ‘go-get-em’ kind of bloke. At times, a bit of a chancer. Some years ago, having convinced his then girlfriend that moving out of London to purchase a renovation project and start a new life in the Welsh countryside, was ‘a good idea’, John soon found himself in financial trouble. Having taken on a large mortgage, he had also under budgeted on the renovation project and borrowed to pay off creditors. Significantly more money was now going out than was coming in. John’s plan had been to gain meaningful well-paid work, a short commute from his new home. It was not to be.
Living in the countryside can be a dream; a living nightmare if you are unable to find work to pay the bills. Week after week, month after month he applied for hundreds of jobs, resulting in numerous interviews, all to no avail. Nine months went by. With thousands of pounds now on his credit card, a significant standing loan against his property, overdrawn on his current account with only £100 remaining ‘in the bank’, a month in arrears on his mortgage, and with little money coming in, John was now in serious trouble. Unopened envelopes littered the dining room table. Having ‘burnt all of his bridges’, unable to deal with the harsh reality, John could see no foreseeable way out. For John, the situation filled him with remorse and with shame. The debts were insurmountable, the writing was on the wall; he believed that he was going to lose his house, that he was about to lose everything. He had options, but he just could not see it. Blue skies were grey. One day, John got in his car and penned a goodbye note. In those dark hours, there appeared to be only one way out. In desperation he asked himself ‘how has it come to this?’ Then, completely out of the blue, in his car, he received a phone call, an ex-colleague phoning to say ‘hello my friend’.
Dear reader: Never underestimate the significance of addressing someone, anyone, as ‘my friend’. Spoken with sincerity, they can become words gift-wrapped in love.
For John, the candle of life had almost been snuffed out. These three little words, ‘hello my friend’, rekindled the fire within him and out of the darkness offered a glimmer of hope.
John now realised that he would have to swallow his pride, and return to London, to ‘the Smoke’, cap in hand so to speak, in order to get work. Any work. Carrying clothes to last him several days, wash kit and a sleeping bag he drove to London and parked his car near Putney Heath, South West London. By day he walked the streets of Putney and Roehampton, rubbing shoulders with and befriending locals and down and outs, in time becoming almost one with them. By night, he slept in his car. After a few days his mobile phone rang with an offer of three hours work. He took the job. A couple of days later, six hours work. From his car, John washed and shaved at the side of the road, polished his shoes, before putting on a suit and tie to then take the tube into Town for a regular twelve hour shift. He would return after work to his car to try and catch some sleep. Every week or so, John would drive back to Wales for a hot bath and several sets of clean clothing, before dashing back to London. And so it continued. After two months of this routine, he thought that he’d had enough. The hours were long, the money pitiful, and he remained living from his car. It was about this time that he was accepted for an interview as a researcher, based in Mayfair, London. Something completely different to what he had been doing. John, utterly capable, viewed this as a tremendously exciting prospect. Although successful in the interview, in the end, he did not get the job. It was not meant to be. Several books had been proffered as suggested reading to prepare for the interview. One book resonated with him ‘Good to Great’ by Jim Collins, and a particular chapter entitled ‘Face the brutal facts – The Stockdale Paradox’.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #3 of Bedrock Magazine.
I stood at the bottom of a long flight of stairs in Monument Station. My six month old was in her buggy, and Monument has no step free access. This important fact had slipped my mind.
Finance Bros jogged past, gym bags slung over their shoulders, taking efficient advantage of their lunch hour. It didn’t seem to occur to any of them that their workout could include helping me carry a buggy. I wasn’t even sure I could stop a Finance Bro without causing some kind of muscled pile up. They were moving so quickly, so intent on keeping to their tight schedules, that diverting any of them seemed tantamount to needing a transport truck to brake suddenly on the highway.
As I worked through possibilities, another mother appeared at the top of the stairs. She registered the steps, her buggy, and the need for help. Waving to her, I put the brakes on my own buggy, and jogged up. We could help each other. Upon reaching her, I realised she was heavily pregnant. There was no way she should be hauling buggies up and down stairs.
Increasingly angry at the inhospitable world around us, I was propelled to uncharacteristic boldness and approached the only stationary people I could see: a group of construction workers, leaning against a wall, eating sandwiches. Hearing my predicament, two of them accompanied me into the station, carried one buggy down, and one buggy up. We were on our way.
My recent pregnancy, and all the small moments where I had felt something I had never really felt before—vulnerable, in need of help, and unsure of whom to turn to—flooded my mind. Severe hyperemesis at the start, high risk throughout; my pregnancy was difficult. It was the first time I felt fearful, protective of myself, and clearly aware of all the ways in which I was weaker than I wanted to be. I was a body inhabited, in the service of another who needed me in such a complete way that all my ingrained habits of self-sufficiency were no longer enough.
Through the months of pregnancy I travelled on the Tube, nauseous, dizzy, exhausted, weighted down. I was never once offered a seat. If, finally desperate, I asked for one, I was met with anything from mild inconvenience to eye rolling disdain.
Through these months, a long lost memory continuously flashed through my mind’s eye. Ten years previously, I was walking to one of the classroom buildings of my University, chatting to a friend. As we approached the double doors, I leapt forward to open one. My friend shook his head. ‘You shouldn’t do that, you know. It’s good for you, and it’s good for me if you let me open the door.’
I stared at him in non comprehension. It’s not like I needed his help to open the door. I had absorbed what was floating in the ether—a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle. I could open my own doors, thank you very much.
It was only when I became pregnant that I began to make sense of what he had said. It was only with the acceptance of motherhood that I felt throughout my body, in an undeniable way, the reality of the differences between the sexes. Until that point, basically anything I wanted to do I could do as well as any man in my orbit.
In theory, there were some things that men could do better than I, like be in combat and lift weights. In reality, ninety eight percent of the men I knew were indistinguishable from me. Our parts were different, but our day to day lives were the same. We crammed for the same classes, typed on computers, talked on phones, rushed through cities, and hung out in the same restaurants and bars. Why would I need a man to open a door for me?
Motherhood woke me up. The difference between the sexes, so easily glossed over or denied completely in our office-job, sterile world laid me flat. The embodied experience of motherhood was an experience of being grounded in undeniable, unshifting reality, but a reality grossly at odds with the world around me. And there lay the rub.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #2 of Bedrock Magazine.
The great majority of young graduates today will find themselves earning their daily bread by the sweat of their fingers—at the mouse and the keyboard. Whether they work in finance or pharmaceuticals, somehow the quotidian performance of their jobs will look awfully similar. Each day a commute to the office to sit before a blueish screen, hammering out the day’s work in clicks and taps.
At one time in Britain, this was not so. Before the expansion of the larger towns and cities, most ordinary folk were engaged either in agricultural labour or some form of artisanry. These people were closely tied to the land they worked, and they produced tangible, often beautiful objects through their own skill and ingenuity. Our times are markedly different—we certainly are not bound to the land in our modern work, and we rarely make anything more tangible than a spreadsheet or a PowerPoint presentation.
So how did we get here? It’s always tempting to engage in a game of infinite regress to pinpoint the origin of any given situation in the modern day. Maybe we were doomed to this fate when the first of our ancestors sharpened a flattish stone and tied it to a stick. But it seems clear to me that the Industrial Revolution, and later de-industrialisation, were the periods which marked a definitive turning point in Britain away from us being a nation of labourers and artisans towards a more consolidated society of workers and technicians.
The Industrial Revolution and the expansion of production efficiency largely doomed widespread traditional artisanry. This was well understood by its opponents within the Arts and Crafts movement like John Ruskin and William Morris who saw the dispossessing effect that industrialisation had, not only on the decorative arts but on craftsmanship more generally. They rightly surmised that the proliferation of industrial manufacturing would alienate the worker from his work, particularly through the division of labour—that is, the separation of work into discrete tasks, each of which is done by a different person.
Later, the post-industrial period would see the decline of even repetitive factory-based labour, to be replaced first by periods of widespread unemployment, and then, following the technological revolutions in computing, with the kind of work we are well acquainted with today. Even the old clerical tasks in which would once have relied on the fountain pen for their performance are now subsumed by the inevitable keyboard.
Working at a computer is not per se wrong or spiritually undignified. I might even concede that we can approach this type of work with a kind of stoicism, accepting that this is simply the way most professional people make a living nowadays. I do, however, believe that when this kind of work pervades most of our waking hours and our leisure time is spent in like manner in front of a screen, then as the Dutch say—we hebben een serieus probleem.
Let us consider for a moment what we are actually doing when we sit down to work in the modern day. The computer, the mouse, the keyboard—these are the tools of our trade. When combined with our intellect, we use these with a certain degree of creativity to earn our living. On the face of it, we could say this is similar to the way in which a carpenter uses his chisels and planes, in tandem with his skill, to eke out his living. But the carpenter understands his tools, knows them through years of use. As far as most of us are concerned, the computers we work with might as well be black boxes full of magic. As John Ruskin prophesied, we have indeed become alienated from our tools.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #2 of Bedrock Magazine.
“There is no such thing as a baby. There is only a baby and someone” – Donald Winnocott. Writing this whilst nine months pregnant, I am acutely aware that my baby is utterly dependent on me. Even after birth, he or she will be completely reliant on me and my husband to cater to every need be that warmth, shelter, food, love.
And yet, it is not just babies who are radically dependent on others. As the journalist Louise Perry rephrased in her hard-hitting bestseller The Case Against the Sexual Revolution, we can go further and say that there is no such thing as a person, only a person and someone. In the normal course of things, the dependency that we experience through infancy and childhood is replaced by caring for dependents, and then, in our later years is brought full circle as we experience dependency again. Even in that so-called independent period of young adulthood, it does not take much imagination to realise that we are still dependent on so many people to keep ourselves fed and watered at the most basic level, and that we also need others to meet out higher desires for love, intellectual pursuits and creativity, for example.
Despite this ubiquitous experience of interdependence, we seem so uncomfortable with it as a society. One stark and timely example is that of the current debate around assisted suicide, as Kim Leadbeater’s Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill makes its way through Parliament. In much of the discussion of the Bill, I have noticed an underlying fear of dependency: fear of being a burden on loved ones or on the State; fear of being dependent on certain medications or technologies to continue living; fear of not having control over our ultimate end.
I notice this fear in myself. Even though I am very much at the stage of my pregnancy when I could do with a bit of extra help, I am resistant. When my husband offers to do things for me, I still cling to my ability to do it myself, even if it leaves me exhausted, breathless, irritable. I fear being dependent.
I was recently talking with a friend about our weddings. We both identified feeling overwhelmed and somewhat uncomfortable by the outpouring of generosity that we received in the months and weeks around our wedding days. We recognised that there were people who had been so abundantly generous in their love and practical support (my dear sister-in-law cleaning a scuff mark off my wedding shoes with a toothbrush at 11.30pm is but a tiny example that springs to mind) that we felt it was impossible to ever repay them.
What was it about such gratuitous care that left us feeling uneasy?
We live in a culture of reciprocity: you scratch my back, I scratch yours. Everything comes at a price, even if it seems free. Consider that ‘free’ email address and storage you have from Google – it comes at the cost of your data feeding the mega-corporation. That ‘free’ coffee you were given as a reward for your loyalty comes at the cost of buying nine others at an inflated price. We are so used to this economy that we don’t know what to do in the face of actions that are completely gratuitous. And we certainly don’t know what to do when we have to depend on the selfless giving of another for our very existence, despite the fact that that is how every single person begins their life (and will often end it).
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #1 of Bedrock Magazine.
Until recent times, the concept of virtue – and particularly the four cardinal virtues of classical philosophy of prudence, justice, temperance and fortitude – was well established in Western thought as the means by which humanity could attain its full potential. When Agathon, in Plato’s Symposium, rises to give a speech in praise of love, he organises his thought around these four virtues and takes it as a given that those in attendance will understand why. It was already established and taken for granted the idea of virtue, signifying ‘rightness’, and these four as the correct definition of it.
The concept of virtue is an interesting one in modern society. It is often associated with adopting a certain viewpoint rather than action or character. Alternatively, it has garnered negative connotations – the ubiquitous ‘virtue-signalling’. Looking like you are trying to ensure everyone knows you have the right viewpoint rather than caring very much about it.
It has also become impossible to ignore the number of ‘good deeds’ now filmed and posted on social media. It’s unclear what these are meant to demonstrate other than the loveliness of the person involved (and of course generate likes and views and, presumably, additional cash as a result).
However, it was not always thus. Virtue in the traditional sense has much to teach us in modern society about how to achieve contentment, happiness and fulfilment that goes beyond the immediate self-affirming dopamine hit that much of the above has come to represent. I am also of the view that there is, within modern society, a craving for genuine virtue. The modern emphasis on individual achievement and personal development has its roots in the desire to develop good character which comes to us from the heart of ancient Greek philosophy. We can point to some outstanding examples of it in modern life and, in disagreement with the quote at the start of the article, there is plenty I think out there to give us hope that virtue is about to experience a renaissance in a very modern context. The start of it though comes down to an individual seeking it.
So what is virtue? And why should we care?
There are numerous definitions throughout history pointing us in the right direction. The classical one is Aristotle’s ‘the golden mean between two excesses, the one of excess and the other of deficiency’. Thomas Aquinas writes that ‘happiness is acquired through virtue; it is a good attained through man’s own will’. A more modern take comes from Alex Havard, founder of the Virtuous Leadership Institute. ‘Virtues are qualities of the mind, the will and the heart that instil strength of character and stability of personality. They are acquired through repetition’. In modern life it feels necessary to give the definition from google:
All of these definitions give indications of the shape that virtue takes, and also why we should continue to care about virtue in the modern world. All (bar google) have written reams on virtue. For Aristotle the virtuous man was worthy of great things (for him, this meant honour) but did not seek these as virtue and the development of character was honour enough. Its own reward. Aquinas took a subtly different take – the virtuous man was worthy of achieving great things, reflective of his understanding of Christian teaching and that Christ had come to gift humanity’s salvation. Havard sees virtue as, amongst other things, the heart of true leadership. Ultimately, all of these point in different ways to the idea that true greatness comes from having the continual development of good/better character and that it is in the virtues we have the means to do so. The pursuit of virtue is therefore, ultimately, the pursuit of human perfection. And through that, man finds happiness to the extent that is possible in this lifetime.
It is worth pausing briefly on this question of pursuing happiness, particularly in the question of why virtue should matter to us. Is it really true that happiness is dependent on virtuous living? I think a brief look at our own lives is likely to provide the answer.
***
Enjoying this article? To read the full piece and explore more thought-provoking content, subscribe and get access to Issue #1 of Bedrock Magazine.